Property management in Paris: comparing mandate, insurance and operator lease
Handing over your Paris apartment does not mean the same thing depending on the contract you sign. This page compares three options: the classic management mandate, unpaid-rent insurance and a lease to an operator such as Belvie, to help you choose with full knowledge.
One question to ask: who carries the risk?
Every property management offer promises to take care of everything. Yet they rest on very different legal set-ups. The difference has nothing to do with how serious the provider is. It comes down to a simple question: who is the tenant of your apartment?
If the occupant signs with you, you remain the landlord and the uncertainty stays on your side. If the provider signs the lease with you and becomes your tenant, the uncertainty changes sides. Our article management mandate or operator lease develops this test in detail; the lines below summarise it.
Option 1: the classic management mandate
Under a mandate, you give a professional the power to act in your name and on your behalf. The lease is signed between you and the occupant, and you receive the rent, which passes through the manager's account before being paid on to you.
The manager looks for the tenant, builds the file, drafts the lease, carries out the inspection reports, collects rent, calls service charges, coordinates repairs and sends you a management statement. In return, it takes fees expressed as a percentage of the rent collected, often with extra services billed separately.
What the mandate does not change
The manager acts in your place, but does not take the burden on itself. If the tenant stops paying, it sends reminders and starts the proceedings, but the missing rent is still missing for you. If the apartment stays empty between two occupants, you receive nothing and charges keep running. If works are needed, the cost is yours. The cost items are analysed in the real cost of rental management in Paris.
Option 2: unpaid-rent insurance
Unpaid-rent insurance is not management: it is an insurance contract taken out by the owner, often on top of a mandate. If the tenant stops paying, the insurer compensates after the loss. It is billed as a percentage of the insured rent.
This protection comes with conditions: a tenant file that meets the insurer's criteria, compensation caps, a deductible, sometimes a waiting period and a maximum period of cover. So it covers neither every tenant nor every scenario, and it does not address vacancy. See our comparison unpaid-rent insurance or guaranteed rent.
Option 3: a lease to an operator, the Belvie model
With Belvie there is no mandate. You sign a lease with Belvie, which becomes your tenant, in Paris only. It then sublets the furnished apartment to professionals on assignment and pays you a fixed rent set in advance, paid every month, whether the apartment is occupied or not.
Unpaid rent, vacancy and day-to-day management therefore sit on Belvie's side, with a single point of contact. In return, the rent is set in advance and includes the operator's margin, and you no longer choose the final occupant. The guaranteed rent in Paris page presents this offer in detail, and Airbnb-style tourist rental is not part of it.
Delegated tasks: what changes with each option
A concierge service or a manager can take over most of the tasks that weigh on an owner. Our article what a rental concierge does for you describes them in the order they arise:
- before letting: setting the right rent, deciding on works and furnishing, gathering diagnostics, photographing the property and writing the listing;
- finding the occupant: posting the listing, sorting applications, checking files, organising viewings, drafting the lease and the entry inspection report;
- during occupancy: collecting rent, issuing receipts, settling service charges, following the occupant's insurance, dealing with the building manager;
- for the unexpected: taking the call, assessing urgency, finding a tradesperson, approving the quote, checking the work;
- at exit: exit inspection, deciding on any deductions, restoring the apartment and relaunching the marketing.
Delegating tasks does not transfer the risk. Under a mandate, the agency works for you; under an operator lease, running the apartment becomes your tenant's business.
What remains the owner's responsibility
Whatever the option, you remain the owner. The property stays yours, with its charges, taxation and structural upkeep. This deserves saying plainly, because no offer removes everything.
Among the items that come with ownership rather than management, the article on management costs notably lists:
- repairs that fall to the landlord and the replacement of equipment in a furnished apartment;
- the non-recoverable share of building charges and works voted at the owners' meeting;
- mandatory diagnostics to be renewed periodically;
- non-occupant landlord insurance;
- property tax.
To clarify with Belvie before signing
With an operator lease, the split of major maintenance and compliance of the apartment must be set out in writing beforehand. The standard contract can be read on the guaranteed rent standard contract page, with no commitment.
Who is each option suited to?
There is no universal answer, but there are fairly clear profiles.
The management mandate
It suits you if you want to keep control over the choice of tenant, accept variable income, own an apartment that lets easily all year, and wish to keep a direct link with the occupant while offloading the day-to-day work.
Unpaid-rent insurance
It is best understood as a complementary protection to a mandate, if your tenant is insurable and you accept its conditions, caps and deductibles. It settles neither vacancy nor the management workload.
The operator lease
It suits you if your priority is regularity rather than the theoretical maximum, if you live far from Paris or abroad, if you no longer want to make decisions, or if vacancy and unpaid rent are precisely what made you hesitate. See also remote rental management from abroad.
How to choose: a simple method
Before comparing two brochures, ask yourself: in the month my apartment earns nothing, who loses money? If the answer is "me", you are under a mandate, however broad the service. If the answer is "the provider", you are under a lease.
Then compare what you collect net over a full year, vacancy and extra fees included, rather than two advertised percentages. The article on rental vacancy in Paris shows why this item is often underestimated. Finally, the seven questions to ask before handing over the keys work with any provider.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a management mandate and an operator lease?
Under a mandate, the lease is signed between you and the occupant, and the manager acts in your name. Under an operator lease, you sign with the operator, which becomes your tenant. The risk of unpaid rent and vacancy then changes sides.
Does a management mandate protect against unpaid rent?
No. The manager sends reminders and starts proceedings, but the missing rent remains your loss. Protection requires a separate insurance contract, with its own conditions.
What does unpaid-rent insurance cover?
It compensates the owner after a payment default, within the caps, deductibles and conditions of the policy. It requires a tenant file that meets the insurer's criteria. It does not address vacancy.
Does Belvie take a management mandate?
No. Belvie signs a lease with you and becomes your tenant. It then sublets the furnished apartment to professionals on assignment, and pays you a fixed rent set in advance, paid every month.
Which tasks are no longer mine with Belvie?
Finding occupants, viewings, inspection reports, handling day-to-day incidents, cleaning and monitoring the occupants' payments are Belvie's. You keep a single point of contact.
What remains my responsibility under an operator lease?
The property stays yours: property tax, the taxation of your income, major maintenance and compliance remain the owner's responsibility unless the contract says otherwise. Have this split set out in writing before signing.
Can I choose my tenant with Belvie?
No, since the final occupant is Belvie's subtenant. However, the permitted use, the target profiles and the lengths of stay are set in the lease before signing.
Which option fits your apartment?
Estimate for free the fixed rent Belvie could pay you, then compare it calmly with the other solutions.
Estimate my rent